Cover of the textbook Speakout Advanced Plus - Students' Book

Answer for exercise 4

The solution for exercise 4 in chapter 3.2 - Fired! of Speakout Advanced Plus - Students' Book by Frances Eales and Steve Oakes

Question

Read the article and underline the most appropriate form, active or passive. Give reasons to support your choices.

Answer

1 - Being disrespected.

  • It becomes clear later over this sentence and the next that Alan Sanford is the object of disrespect here, and that it's not disrespecting people in general that makes him mad.

2 - a customer left him

  • We need a subject here because later in the sentence there is a reference back to 'the person' and we need to establish which person this is.

3 - took a photo of the person

  • It would be unrealistic for AS to ask for and pay someone to take the photo.
  • He obviously took the photo himself and so the active is appropriate.

4 - he was fired

  • The active here would be confusing as 'they' seems to refer to both the colleagues and the boss, which would be impossible.
  • Using the passive also keeps the focus on Sanford, the main focus of the paragraph.

5 - I could have been given

  • The subject of the active sentence 'He' would be unclear. It also becomes clear in number 6 that Sanford is the focus of the sentence.

6 - being sacked

  • An -ing form is needed after a preposition.

7 - can't be said

  • isn't said is not wrong, but makes it sound as if people actively talk about how interesting flipping burgers is (or not)
  • can't be said conveys the notion 'if people were to talk about this ... '

8 - to have her video taken

  • Reading ahead, a subject (her video) is needed for the verb posted.
  • To be videoed would later imply that Jackie is posted rather than her video,

9 - She shouldn't have posted the video.

  • The passive here is not incorrect.
  • However, if we want to maintain the focus on the colleague (I'm very angry with my colleague) it is better to maintain the colleague as the subject (She).

10 - to be said

  • This is a fixed phrase which is almost always in the passive.