The key answer of exercise 11
The key to exercise solutions in chapter 8 - Presentation and practice 2 for the textbook Performer B1, Vol. 2 with authors Marina Spiazzi, Marina Tavella e Margaret Layton from Zanichelli
Question
Debate the following statement: I believe that museums should be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week, with free access for everyone, and without compulsory itineraries or security guards. Choose two students to speak in favour of the statement and two to speak against it. Then vote for the couple you found more convincing.
Answer
Arguments in favor:
Accessibility and inclusivity:
- Inclusivity: 24/7 access promotes inclusivity, allowing individuals with varied schedules, including those with unconventional working hours, to enjoy cultural experiences at their convenience.
- Free access: Removing financial barriers by offering free admission ensures that cultural enrichment is accessible to all socio-economic groups.
Fostering a culture of continuous learning:
- Lifelong learning: Extended opening hours encourage a culture of continuous learning, enabling people to engage with art and history at any time, fostering intellectual growth and curiosity.
- Flexibility: Offering flexible visiting hours accommodates diverse learning styles and preferences, allowing visitors to explore exhibits at their own pace.
Promoting autonomy and enjoyment:
- Autonomy: Eliminating compulsory itineraries grants visitors the freedom to explore exhibits according to their interests and preferences, enhancing the overall museum experience.
- No security guards: Trusting visitors with an open and unguarded environment promotes a sense of responsibility and respect for cultural heritage.
Arguments against:
Security concerns:
- Preservation: The absence of security guards could pose a risk to the preservation of valuable artifacts and artworks, potentially leading to theft, vandalism, or accidental damage.
- Emergency situations: An unmonitored environment may be more susceptible to emergencies, making it challenging to respond promptly to situations like natural disasters or accidents.
Operational costs:
- Financial burden: Operating a museum 24/7 incurs higher costs for utilities, staffing, and maintenance, potentially straining the museum's budget and diverting resources from other essential areas.
- Sustainability: The environmental impact of maintaining facilities around the clock, including energy consumption, may conflict with sustainability goals.
Visitor experience management:
- Crowd control: Unrestricted access at all times might lead to overcrowding, compromising the quality of the visitor experience and making it challenging to manage peak times effectively.
- Guided experience: Compulsory itineraries, when well-designed, can enhance the educational experience by providing context, thematic cohesion, and ensuring that visitors engage with key exhibits.
In conclusion, while 24/7 museum access with free entry promotes inclusivity and continuous learning, concerns about security, operational costs, and managing the visitor experience highlight the need for a balanced approach that considers both accessibility and the preservation of cultural heritage.
Similar Books
