The key answer of exercise 5
The key to exercise solutions in chapter Trending Topics 6 for the textbook Identity B1+ with authors Elizabeth Sharman from Oxford University Press
Question
Make a list of reasons why the New York youth courts are a positive thing. Then write a list of reasons why people might criticise them. Use the information in the text and the topics below.
Answer
Positive aspects of New York youth courts
- Education and rehabilitation opportunities.
- Positive role models and community involvement.
- Emphasis on accountability and restorative justice.
- Potential cost-effectiveness and avoidance of criminal records.
Possible criticisms of New York youth courts
- Perceived leniency and lack of punishment.
- Limited deterrence and inequity in sentencing.
- Skepticism about effectiveness and resource allocation.
- Overlooking victims' needs and impact on prison conditions.